At the top of our seventh show it was time for another hopeful to leave the competition. But first Amanda announced which two Jesuses had come bottom in the public vote.
David and Tim would now face the dreaded sing-off. They would be performing The Beatles' classic The Long and Winding Road. It's a song they'd all been rehearsing but no one wanted to sing.
Andrew first gave his notes. He said it wasn't what he expected. It's got to be about breathing and phrasing, he pointed out.
But in a shock twist he decided that he wouldn't send either home after the sing-off, but after all of our remaining hopefuls sang.
Andrew said in an ideal world he wouldn't want either in the bottom in the two, but - with his producer's hat - on he saved David, but he was sure Tim really had a future in musical theatre.